Study 034 · Sin and the New Creation, Part 7 of 8
Why we do not keep asking, and what true repentance is
Hello again, dear friends, and welcome to Part 7. In Part 6, we saw that victory over temptation does not come by willpower, but by resting in Christ and praising Him for the victory He has already won. (see: Sin and the New Creation – Part 6: Victory at Rest)
Now we come to a question that touches the daily habits of many believers. Should Christians keep asking God to forgive them?
1. Sin-conscious Christians
Many Christians believe they must ask God for forgiveness for their sins all the time. For some, it has become almost an obsession, because they have been conditioned to be extremely sin-conscious.
But here is the truth. God poured out forgiveness for all, the very moment Jesus died on the cross. So, when we plead with God to forgive us, we are asking Him to do something He already did about 2,000 years ago. In essence, we are not believing what He has done.
It does not matter how sorry you are, how many tears you cry, or how sincere your remorse is. From the standpoint of Scripture, you can be sincerely wrong!
2. What true repentance is
Our task is to acknowledge the truth: Jesus gave His life and established the New Covenant of forgiveness at His death on the cross, and we were forgiven of the debt of sin at that very moment. So, by faith we look back at that fact. We acknowledge it, we believe it and we rest in it.
That is the true meaning of repentance. The Greek word is metanoia, a change of mind. It is turning to Christ in faith, believing what He has accomplished.
3. Who did need to ask?
The only people who had to keep seeking God’s forgiveness through sacrifice were the Hebrews, who lived under the administration of the Law of Moses until AD 70.
The Sinaitic Covenant was added alongside the Abrahamic Covenant, which already existed. The first was a covenant of grant, based on God’s promise and grace. The second was a vassal covenant, based on obedience. And the second covenant came with a sacrificial system that pointed prophetically to the coming Messiah. Each year, the season of Teshuvah, repentance, led up to Yom Kippur, the Day of Atonement.
Those blood sacrifices were a shadow of Christ, who was still in Israel’s future. So, I like to say that under the law, Israel received forgiveness “on credit”, on the basis that Christ would one day end all sacrifices and secure forgiveness for the whole human race.
Breaking the Law of Moses was a breach of that covenant, and it brought the wrath of God. Every contract has terms and conditions, and the law was the terms and conditions of that covenant. The only way out of the covenant was to die. The Jewish believers who followed Christ understood that they had died with Him and risen into a new life. They were no longer bound to keep the old covenant. Those who believed in Christ between the cross and AD 70 knew they had received God’s forgiveness, and that they would never again need to bring a sin offering. (see: Sin and the New Creation – Part 5: No Old Covenant, No Wrath)
4. What about saying sorry?
Do Christians today need to say sorry? If you know you have hurt someone, it is right to make amends where you can. That is a basic, healthy principle in human relationships. An apology expresses your remorse, and your willingness to put things right.
But God is not asking us to apologise to Him, or to fix things with Him. He is asking us to believe Him: to trust that what Christ did forever sealed the New Covenant of forgiveness. Then we can learn to live from our position of righteousness in Christ.
5. “Paid, but did not forgive”?
I once read an article in which a preacher wrote, “Jesus paid for the sins of this world on the cross, but did not forgive.” That makes no sense at all.
Other books explain that although Christ died for the whole world, and forgiveness is available to everyone, we must ask God in faith to forgive us in order to “appropriate” it. But do we appropriate forgiveness by asking Him to forgive what He already forgave? No. We act on our faith in the fact that we were forgiven. We thank Him that He did forgive, and so our heart and mind come to experience that forgiveness.
To forgive means that all outstanding debt is removed. Guilt is replaced with forgiveness, followed by reconciliation and peace.
And here is another point to keep in mind. If Jesus paid the Father by being punished in our place, then His sacrifice was a payment. But if a debt is paid, it is not forgiven. Forgiveness means no payment is required. If the company you owe money to rings to say they have forgiven your debt, you would be entitled to ask for all your monthly payments back!
So, it was not an acquittal, as when a court finds someone not guilty. We were guilty, but we were pardoned. Jesus’ sacrifice was the means by which He established the New Covenant, the basis on which God forgives and gives His righteousness as a gift to all. I will set out the full case in a later series on the wrath of God and the cross.
6. Reconciled
God reconciled us to Himself in Christ long before you were born. That moment on the cross was the moment your sins were forgiven, and its effect reached in every direction: past, present and future.
To wit, that God was in Christ, reconciling the world unto himself, not imputing their trespasses unto them; and hath committed unto us the word of reconciliation.
2 Corinthians 5:19 (KJV)
To be reconciled means to be made friends again. The related Greek noun, katallagē, is the word the King James Version translates “atonement” in Romans 5:11. It comes from a verb meaning “to change” or “to exchange”, and in everyday Greek it could even describe the business of the money-changers.1 Reconciliation is an exchange: our sin for His righteousness.
7. Why would He forgive you now?
When you ask God to forgive you, you must also believe that He has not forgiven you until you ask. So, why would He forgive you now? Because of your sincere remorse? Your tears? Your feelings of regret?
Judas Iscariot also became deeply emotional when he realised what he had done. He showed regret, and shed many tears, before he took his own life. Why? I believe it is a safe assumption that he could not believe what Jesus’ death would mean. Had he believed it, he could have taken hold of the gift of forgiveness that was about to be released at Jesus’ death.
And if you ask for forgiveness simply because everyone in your Church does it, and it is tradition, I would gently say: make a decision. What if the tradition does not line up with Scripture? Either stay with the tradition or go with what the Scriptures say.
It is normal to feel regret and remorse. And those feelings are hugely important, if they lead you to embrace the truth that you were already forgiven. That is true repentance, and that is how you honour the tremendous work Christ finished for you. Confessing your sins on its own has nothing to do with repentance. But acknowledging what you did wrong, and believing you were forgiven because you died in His death and your new life is hidden in His life, now that is powerful.
8. Coming up next
In Part 8, the final part of this series, we will look at the great exchange of 2 Corinthians 5:21, the marriage illustration in Romans 7, and why everyone born after the cross, including you, was born righteous in Christ.
Until then, stop asking, and start thanking. You were forgiven before you were born.
Grace and peace to you.
Pat the GospelMan
First published in German on 28 May 2018, and in English on 3 December 2022. Revised and divided into a series, 2026.
Sin and the New Creation · Part 7 of 8
← Part 6 · All 8 parts · Part 8 →
Bibliography
Thayer, Joseph Henry, A Greek-English Lexicon of the New Testament (American Book Company, 1889).
The Holy Bible, King James Version (1611).
Notes
- Joseph Henry Thayer, A Greek-English Lexicon of the New Testament (American Book Company, 1889), s.v. καταλλαγή. ↩︎
