Study 031 · Sin and the New Creation, Part 4 of 8
A good servant, but a harsh master
Hello again, dear friends, and welcome to Part 4. In Part 3, we saw that the law of sin and death is a principle, not a nature, and that it is set in motion when we try to earn acceptance with God. (see: Sin and the New Creation – Part 3: The Law of Sin and Death)
Now we come to the conscience. Let me say clearly at the start: the conscience is not the enemy. It is a gift, and it has a very good purpose. The trouble begins at one specific point, and once you see it, a great deal falls into place.
1. What the conscience is
The conscience is the faculty of our mind by which we judge what is right and what is wrong, what is to be blamed and what can be excused. Our standard of right and wrong is shaped by our upbringing, our culture and, for many, our religion. So, it is partly personal and subjective.
Which shew the work of the law written in their hearts, their conscience also bearing witness, and their thoughts the mean while accusing or else excusing one another;
Romans 2:15 (KJV)
The conscience is also meant to grow:
But strong meat belongeth to them that are of full age, even those who by reason of use have their senses exercised to discern both good and evil.
Hebrews 5:14 (KJV)
Let me be clear about what this verse is, and is not, describing. It is not the gift of discerning of spirits (1 Corinthians 12:10). That gift is a work of the Holy Spirit, not of the conscience. When a prophetic word is spoken, or the Spirit is moving in a meeting, we test it first and foremost against the written Word of God. And the Holy Spirit bears witness with our spirit, so that deep in our soul we sense His fruit, love, joy, peace, longsuffering, gentleness, goodness, faith, meekness and temperance, and we know, “Yes, this is God at work.” That inner knowing does not come from the conscience.
What Hebrews 5:14 describes is the everyday maturity of believers who, “by reason of use”, have exercised their senses in the Word of God. Day after day we are surrounded by ideologies, philosophies, religious ideas and political agendas. Some people do “good” things with hidden motives. Others mean well, but cannot see where a decision made today will lead ten years from now. Many of these things sound good and appear good, but they are not good. A mature believer, rooted and grounded in the Gospel, and in God’s Word understood in its context, sees the world through that light, and so learns to recognise what is of God and what is not.
2. Guilt, and how we try to escape it
When we know we have done something wrong by our own standard, our inner dialogue begins to accuse us, and we feel guilt. Guilt is painful, and the mind looks for a way to relieve it.
Without a revelation of the finished work of Christ, people are left to their own devices. Some shift the blame onto others. Some find ways to excuse themselves. And religion, by which I mean any system of earning God’s favour, offers a list of works to perform. Confess this, do that, live up to the group’s expectations, and eventually the accusing voice goes quiet. Enough good works seem to bring relief from guilt, which is really another word for debt.
But doing good works to pay off the debt of sin is penance. It is payment. It is not forgiveness. That is why people who live by any religious system end up serving the demands of their conscience. They become its slaves.
3. The accuser’s oldest trick
Consider how this works. All the accuser needed to do to keep mankind trapped was to make people believe they were not good enough for God. That idea breeds the next one: you must do something to become good enough.
So the lie comes: “You are not good enough.” The conscience agrees. Then: “So you are not accepted.” And people climb onto a treadmill of works, trying to earn the acceptance they think they lack. Some are very disciplined, and get a lot of the “good works” right. But it never matters. It will never be good enough. The treadmill of self-righteousness is designed to make you fail, because all it takes is one failure in one area.
4. The reward system
God has also built a reward system into our brain and body. When we achieve something we value, the brain releases dopamine, and we feel good. It is a good design, and it serves us well in everyday life.
But think about what happens when it works together with a self-righteous conscience. I have prayed, I have fasted, I went to Church faithfully, I read my Bible, and I kept all the high religious standards I set for myself. Then I look at myself and think, “I have done well.” The reward system kicks in, and I feel really good, because now I feel I have done enough to be accepted by God.
The trouble is that the same principle works against us the moment we think we have not done enough. Then the very same conscience begins to accuse us, and the good feeling gives way to guilt and fear. Scientists have studied the brain’s reward system extensively, and what they have found only confirms what the Word of God already teaches. Acceptance that has to be earned is never secure. Acceptance that is a gift can never be lost.
5. Jesus ended the cycle
Jesus came to end that cycle. The old man, the identity rooted in Adam, was crucified with Him. In this way, Jesus killed three flies with one swat:
1. He removed the sin nature and gave us His resurrection life, in which we are forever accepted by the Father.
2. Because we are one with the Lord, there are no good works we can do to earn this union, and no bad works that can break it.
3. If you believe the first two, the accuser can never again condemn you, whatever you do right or wrong.
A person who believes what the finished work means does not do good works to get relief from guilt. They know the debt was cancelled. Their good works are the fruit of being forgiven and accepted, not the price for it.
For we are his workmanship, created in Christ Jesus unto good works, which God hath before ordained that we should walk in them.
Ephesians 2:10 (KJV)
Here is a simple picture. You are the child of your biological parents. Nothing you do in life will ever change that fact. Your choices flow largely from how you see yourself, but you remain who you are. Now you know that God is your Father, and Christ is your elder brother. Your choices can begin to reflect that reality. Your conscience is meant to serve you in this, not the other way round.
6. The good conscience
The conscience develops as we learn and grow. So, we need it established in the Gospel, trained to agree that Jesus is our righteousness. When we do something wrong, we can turn to Jesus and reassure our heart, conscience and feelings that we are forgiven and made righteous in Christ. That gives us confidence before God, and access to His grace for victory in the very area we were struggling with.
On the other hand, many people with no knowledge of the Gospel are gradually worn down by corrupting influences, until they become indifferent to evil. Scripture speaks of a conscience “seared with a hot iron” (1 Timothy 4:2), so that what was once known to be wrong now seems right.
So, in and of itself, the conscience serves us well. The problem begins only when it becomes our master: when we believe that doing wrong will bring God’s punishment, and that doing right will earn God’s acceptance. And notice, if you believe you must earn acceptance, you must also believe you are working from a place of non-acceptance. That is a default setting of rejection. It is very toxic, and it is exactly what switches on the law of sin and death.
7. What about the laws of the land?
I want to be clear that I am talking about earning acceptance with God, not about the laws of your country. Keeping the law of the land is important. It protects people and property and keeps society in order, as long as those laws are in harmony with the principle of doing no harm to others. Where laws are unjust, citizens may challenge them in lawful and effective ways. But if we keep the law of the land because we believe it makes us righteous before God, we are back in self-righteousness.
8. Training the conscience
So, how do we train the conscience? Tell it the truth. Not your achievement of holiness, but Christ, is your righteousness. You have been made righteous by Christ, and you are accepted by God because you are in Him. This is a vital part of renewing the mind by the Word of God.
How do you “tell” your conscience anything? It is about bringing your self-talk in line with what Scripture says about you. Profess your faith. I do not mean confessing your sins. I mean speaking Scripture-based truth about who you are in Christ, until your heart, conscience included, is established in it.
9. Love or fear?
How can you tell whether your heart is established in the truth? Look for the fruit of the Spirit:
But the fruit of the Spirit is love, joy, peace, longsuffering, gentleness, goodness, faith, Meekness, temperance: against such there is no law.
Galatians 5:22-23 (KJV)
Notice, “fruit”, singular. It is one fruit, and it is love: not your love, but God’s love for you at work in you. From it flow joy, peace and the rest, which we experience as feelings.
That is why our emotions are a useful gauge. The word emotion comes from the Latin emovere, “to move out”. An emotion is a movement we feel in our body when we think strongly about something. And I believe all our feelings are ultimately rooted in either love or fear. Fear shows itself as anger, panic, worry, anxiety, a sense of rejection or of being unworthy.
So, ask yourself: what has been your most dominant emotion today? This week? This month? This year? Is it rooted in love? If it is rooted in fear, that tells you something about what you believe about yourself, and about how you believe God sees you.
Religion is rooted in self-righteousness, and it runs on fear. I once watched a speaker explain that our expectation of a final judgment, with punishment for wrongdoers, is what gives us a reason to live right. I do not believe that is God’s way. We do right to others because of the revelation of God’s love for us. Yes, we will all stand before God one day, but He has already made His judgment about us. We are in Christ, and so we are righteous. When your heart is established in that, you will want to do right, not out of fear of punishment, but because you see God’s love for others too. (see: The Love of God – Part 10: Love Demands Judgment)
10. Coming up next
In Part 5, we will look at the Law of Moses itself: who it was given to, what kind of covenant it was, and why there is no wrath for you under the New Covenant.
Until then, remember: your conscience is a servant, not your master. Tell it the truth. You are forgiven, righteous and accepted, because you are in Christ.
Grace and peace to you.
Pat the GospelMan
First published in German on 28 May 2018, and in English on 13 November 2022. Revised and divided into a series, 2026.
Sin and the New Creation · Part 4 of 8
← Part 3 · All 8 parts · Part 5 →
Bibliography
The Holy Bible, King James Version (1611).
