The Love of God – Part 10: Love Demands Judgment

A shepherd seen from behind standing watch at the gate of a stone sheepfold at night, his staff and lantern by the wall and the flock resting safely

Study 010 · The Love of God, Part 10 of 13

“Judge not” does not mean “do not care”

Hello, dear friends, and welcome to Part 10. In Part 9, we saw that believing and loving are one commandment, and that the love of God is experienced from within. (see: The Love of God – Part 9: One Commandment, Experienced from Within) Now for a subject that may surprise you. Love and judgment are not enemies. In fact, love demands judgment.

1. “Oh, I’m not judging”

Judgment is not only about God judging and punishing people for their sin. That is a very narrow view. In its wider and deeper sense, judgment is a process of making decisions: assessing and weighing all the available evidence to reach a conclusion.

In the secular world, people often say, “Oh, I’m not judging.” What do they mean? I am not sure they always know. It is a popular thing to say to calm a tense debate. But in Christian circles, “You mustn’t judge” has produced a weak and, I would say, anaemic attitude towards evil. That is exactly what the devil would want: Christians standing passively by when wrong is being done.

Sometimes, it even extends to Church leaders. People refuse to call out wrong behaviour and evil conduct, because “Jesus said, don’t judge”. That is a complete misuse of His words. It does not match the example Jesus gave us in the four Gospels, and it does not fit the New Testament as a whole. Jesus confronted the hypocrisy of the Pharisees, the Sadducees, the scribes, the doctors of the Law and the elders of the community.

2. What Jesus actually said

Jesus never said “judge not” as two words on their own.

Judge not, that ye be not judged. For with what judgment ye judge, ye shall be judged: and with what measure ye mete, it shall be measured to you again.

Matthew 7:1-2 (KJV)

So, what does that mean? It means that the measure you use on others will be used on you. Of course, we assess people’s conduct, good and bad. Think of a job interview. The panel assesses your presentation, how you answer questions, how you communicate, your knowledge and your experience. They are judging, weighing and deciding.

We praise people for good deeds and sometimes reward them in public. That too is a judgment. And of course, we judge bad behaviour, especially when it is criminal and ends up before a court.

But when you judge another person’s conduct, the standard you measure by must also be applied to you. You cannot use two different measures. If you judge another’s behaviour as wrong, but allow yourself to behave the same way and expect to get away with it, you are wrong. The same measure will be applied to you. Jesus often directed this truth at the leaders of His day, who operated a two-tier standard that protected themselves while condemning ordinary people.

3. What about James?

Some passages can cause confusion if they are taken out of context.

Speak not evil one of another, brethren. He that speaketh evil of his brother, and judgeth his brother, speaketh evil of the law, and judgeth the law: but if thou judge the law, thou art not a doer of the law, but a judge. There is one lawgiver, who is able to save and to destroy: who art thou that judgest another?

James 4:11-12 (KJV)

Does James not clearly tell us not to judge our brother? Well, not exactly. He was writing to people who were partial in applying the law. From a self-righteous position, they slandered and accused others, while picking and choosing when the law applied to themselves.

It reminds me of a film I watched recently, The Equalizer 3. (Yes, I watch films.) The villain murders innocent people, then goes to Church to confess his sins while his bodyguards wait outside. Afterwards, he simply carries on murdering. That is the kind of partiality James meant. People like that had no business judging others.

4. Christ’s law applies to all

Paul makes the same point. God shows no partiality, and both those who had the law and those who did not would be judged by the light they had (Romans 2:11-16). True obedience is not about favouritism, but about living by the direction we have been given.

A quick reminder, though. Christians are not without law. We are not under the Law of Moses, but we are under Christ’s law, the new commandment: “love one another; as I have loved you” (John 13:34). The believers James wrote to were quarrelling among themselves (James 4:1). They spoke evil of their own brothers while excusing themselves, as if Christ’s law did not apply to them. By applying it selectively, they made themselves judges of that law.

So, we are called to judge evil from a position of humility, knowing that the same law applies to everyone, ourselves included.

But he giveth more grace. Wherefore he saith, God resisteth the proud, but giveth grace unto the humble. Submit yourselves therefore to God. Resist the devil, and he will flee from you.

James 4:6-7 (KJV)

5. God is love, therefore He judges

Yes, God is love. Is He also a judge? Many Christians today would say no. But God is righteous; that is why He is a judge. And God is love; that is also why He is a judge.

He rightly declared that mankind had fallen into sin, was guilty, and deserved destruction. But because He is a righteous judge, and because He is love, He became a man and took away the sin of the world (John 1:29). He took mankind into Himself and, as the last Adam, put the old creation of the first Adam to death on the cross (1 Corinthians 15:45; 2 Corinthians 5:14). By the resurrection of Christ, mankind was made a new creation, united with Him in His resurrection life.

Jesus established the covenant of forgiveness. And as only a righteous judge can, God judged us forgiven, free from the debt of sin, and righteous in the risen Christ.

6. Love will not stand by

You cannot split judgment from love. If you love the people dearest to you, you will do what you can to stop anyone who tries to harm them, and you will judge that behaviour as evil, or even criminal.

Suppose a pastor is found to be dishonest, and Church money is going missing. That pastor must be called out. It must be done with wisdom, to protect the people of the Church, but it must be done. Even many people who do not yet know Christ have a moral compass that tells them when something is wrong. God wrote the same law in their hearts. They are moved by injustice because they love. If they did not love, they would not care. Love demands the judgment of evil.

In Part 11, we will look at what forgiveness does, and does not, mean; at how judgment changed from the old covenant to the new; and at our responsibility as believers today.

Grace and peace to you.

Pat the GospelMan

First published on 26 May 2025. Revised 2026.


The Love of God · Part 10 of 13
← Part 9 · All 13 parts · Part 11 →

Bibliography

The Holy Bible, King James Version (1611).